CATEGORY

Excellent - 3 pts

Good - 2 pts

Poor - 1 pt

Case Citation

Information in citation is correct and in the correct format.

Information in citation is correct but there are minor errors in formatting.

Information in citation is incorrect and/or there are major errors in formatting.

Facts

Accurately identifies and describes all facts related to case.

Accurately identifies and describes several facts realted to the case.

Idenifies some facts realted to case. Has difficulty accurately decscribing.

Issue

Accurately states issue related to case.

Partially correct in stating issue of case.

Has difficulty identifing issue of case.

Court Decision

Court's decision accurately stated.

Some difficulty in accurately stating Court's decision.

Court's decision not accurately stated.

Reason for Court Decision

Clearly and accurately stated. All criteria for Court's decsion stated.

Some difficlty stating reasoning for Court's decision. Missing some criteria decision based on.

Reasoning for Court's decision not stated. Criteria for Court's decison missing.

Grammar & Spelling

All grammar and/or spelling correct.

Two or less grammar and/or spelling errors.

More than two grammar and/or spelling errors.