La rúbrica fue hecha usando:

RubiStar ( http://rubistar.4teachers.org )

CATEGORY

No Name

No Name

No Name

No Name

Citation

Citation is correctly copied from handout or download. +5 points

Citation is mostly correct. +4 points

 

Citation is mostly incorrect. +0 points

Facts

Demonstrates an excellent understanding of which facts are relevent to the decision. Includes a summary of P's complaint and D's answer. +15 points

Demonstrates a good understanding of which facts are relevant to the decision. Includes summary of P's complaint and D's answer. +10-14 points

Demonstrates a fair understanding of what facts are relevant to the decision. No summary of P and D pleadings. +5-9 points

Demonstrates a poor or no understanding of the facts relevant to the decision. No summary of P's and D's pleadings. +0-4 points

Issue

Demonstrates an excellent understanding of the issue(s) and presents them fully. +15 points

Demonstrates a good understanding of the issue(s) and presents them well. 10-14 points

Demonstrates a fair understanding of the issue(s) and presents them in an understandable way. +5-9 points

Demonstrates a poor understanding or no understanding of the issue(s). +0-4 points

Holding

Demonstrates an excellent understanding of the holding, makes sense when read in light of the Issue. +15 points

Demonstrates a good understanding of the holding, makes sense when read in light of the Issue. +10-14 points

Demonstrates a fair understanding of the holding, somewhat makes sense when read in light of the Issue. +5-9 points

Demonstrates little or no understanding of the holding, makes little or no sense when read in light of the Issue. +0-4 points

Reasoning

Demonstrates an excellent understanding of court's reasoning, expresses it clearly. +15 points

Demonstrates a good understanding of court's reasoning, expresses it well. +10-14 points

Demonstrates a fair understanding of court's reasoning, expresses it in an understandable way. +5-9 points

Demonstrates a poor or no understanding of court's reasoning, expresses it poorly or not at all. +0-4 points